A U.S. jury has ruled that Masimo’s smartwatches infringe on several patents held by tech giant Apple. This verdict, announced on October 25, 2024, could significantly impact both companies and the broader wearable technology market. As smartwatches become increasingly essential for health monitoring and personal fitness, understanding the legal implications of this ruling is crucial for consumers and industry stakeholders.
Photo: Apple
The Details of the Case
Apple filed the lawsuit, claiming that Masimo’s smartwatches use technology protected by its design patents. These patents cover key features that enhance smartwatch functionality and user experience, particularly in health monitoring and biometric data collection. The jury in Delaware agreed with Apple that earlier versions of Masimo’s W1 and Freedom watches, along with their chargers, willfully violated Apple’s patent rights. However, Apple received only $250 in damages, the statutory minimum for infringement.
Implications for Masimo
This verdict may create challenges for Masimo, including restrictions on selling its smartwatches in the U.S., which could impact its revenue and market share. However, the products in question were part of a discontinued module and charger. Masimo expressed satisfaction with the verdict, noting that “Apple primarily sought an injunction against Masimo’s current products…,” which was not granted. As the case unfolds, the consequences will affect both the companies involved and consumers regarding the products available to them. This ruling is just one of many battles between the two companies that may continue in court.
The Fight Continues
Masimo has accused Apple of hiring away employees and stealing its pulse oximetry technology. Last year, Masimo convinced the U.S. International Trade Commission to block imports of various Apple watches. Apple has since appealed this decision and resumed selling the watches, but only after removing their blood oxygen reading capabilities. Additionally, Apple has countersued for patent infringement, alleging that certain features of the Apple Watch were copied.
Want to learn more about filing your own patent application? Need assistance? Feel free to call or email us at (713) 364-4796 or admin@madan-law.com.